Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza in Carle Place

Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza in Carle Place

When New York native Anthony Bruno opened his first restaurant in Florida a few years back we bet he never would have dreamed that that restaurant would have 20+ locations and a popular outpost in the Long Island area. Either way, we’re experiencing the fruits of his labor with Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza in Carle Place.

Anthony’s famous tag line of “Pizza Well Done” means more than just the quality of the pizza. The coal fired oven, hitting temperatures of over 850 degrees leaves a nice char and taste on the pizza and the pie is a little well done on the edges. There’s a good variety of pies available (our favorite is the meatball and ricotta) with a healthy variation on wings, that are grilled and not fried.


Photo Courtesy of Mark Brandon Photography


850 degree oven
Photo Courtesy of Mark Brandon Photography


Meatballs coming out of the oven
Photo Courtesy of Mark Brandon Photography

There’s no slices at Anthony’s; everything is ordered by the pie. They come in 12″ and 16″ varieties. If you can, plan to eat in the restaurant as the pizza loses a majority of its texture once it hits a to-go box. Although they’re only located in Carle Place at the time of this writing, there’s plans in the works to open up a second Woodbury location on Jericho Turnpike within the next few months.


Arugula Pizza
Photo Courtesy of Mark Brandon Photography


Grilled Wings
Photo Courtesy of Mark Brandon Photography


Paul & Young Ron Pizza
Photo Courtesy of Mark Brandon Photography

Anthony’s Coal Fired Pizza
137 Old Country Rd.
Carle Place, NY 11514
516-877-7750
{Google Map | Website | Flickr}

© 2017 East of NYC – Long Island Restaurants, Food News, Shopping, Events and Real Estate
A SLAM Marketing, LLC Website